Bankers used to sweat every annual sign-off. Now a big chunk of that paperwork is getting axed.
In late October 2026, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) rolled out their Phase 2 consultation papers on the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR). Together with the Phase 1 tweaks that landed earlier in 2026, regulators are scaling back pre-approval hurdles, scrapping mandatory annual fitness and propriety certifications for tens of thousands of staff, and leaning harder on firms to police themselves. Regulators estimate the overhaul will save businesses roughly £2 billion over ten years. For an alternative view, check out: this related article.
Let's be honest about what this actually means. Critics call it watering down post-2008 accountability. Watchdogs call it cutting red tape to boost growth and competitiveness. Both sides have a point, and anyone running HR, compliance, or risk in the City who treats this as a free pass is asking for trouble.
Why UK Fit and Proper Rules Are Changing
After the 2008 financial crisis, Britain built one of the toughest individual accountability systems in global finance. The SM&CR, introduced in 2016, was designed to stop executives from hiding behind committees when things blew up. Alongside it sat the Fit and Proper test (FIT), checking honesty, integrity, reputation, competence, capability, and financial soundness. Further insight regarding this has been shared by Business Insider.
Ten years on, compliance teams complain that the regime drowned in box-ticking. I've seen internal teams spend weeks chasing routine annual sign-offs for certified staff whose roles hadn't changed a bit, while actual risk reviews got shortchanged.
In October 2026, the PRA published CP14/26 and the FCA published CP26/37. Under these Phase 2 proposals:
- Mandatory annual fitness and propriety certifications under the Certification Regime would be scrapped for roughly 139,000 FCA-certified staff and around 7,700 PRA-certified staff (with some overlap between the two).
- Pre-approval hurdles for senior roles would shrink. The PRA proposes dropping pre-approval for nearly half of Senior Manager Functions—including Chairs of Risk and Audit Committees and Chief Actuaries—moving them to a notification model instead.
- Reporting timelines and thresholds are loosening. Temporary cover rules are stretching (such as extending temporary cover windows to 18 weeks under the proposals), and financial thresholds for Enhanced SM&CR firms are rising to reflect inflation and size.
Regulators project big cost savings. The FCA estimates annual compliance savings of about £229 million (around 53%), while the PRA estimates central annual savings of £11.5 million (around 47%), largely driven by dropping routine certification.
Does This Mean Bankers Can Get Away With More?
Not automatically, no. Removing a regulatory sign-off is not the same as legalizing bad behavior.
Top executive roles still face strict scrutiny, and the core idea of individual accountability hasn't vanished. Even where pre-approval goes away, firms must still satisfy themselves that a candidate is fit and proper before putting them in a role. Plus, regulators are reserving the right to require pre-approval or step in when a firm shows governance weaknesses or doubts over its fitness and propriety checks.
What is shifting is who carries the day-to-day administrative burden and where regulatory firepower goes. Instead of reviewing endless routine paperwork, watchdogs want to focus on higher-risk appointments and serious misconduct.
The Non-Financial Misconduct Twist Nobody Should Ignore
If you only look at the October 2026 SM&CR consultations, you'll miss half the story.
Just weeks earlier, on 1 September 2026, the FCA's new non-financial misconduct (NFM) rules under PS25/23 came into force across regulated firms. Serious bullying, harassment, and violence between colleagues are explicitly brought into the Conduct Rules (COCON) for all authorised firms, including non-banks.
At the same time, the Fit and Proper (FIT) sourcebook explicitly addresses conduct outside work. Firms aren't expected to snoop on every employee's social media feed or investigate trivial gossip. Still, serious off-duty conduct—or a pattern of behavior that raises real questions about honesty, integrity, or the risk of misconduct repeating—can knock someone's fitness and propriety right off the rails.
In practice, that creates a weird tension. Regulators are trimming routine certification forms on one hand, while sharpening expectations around culture, speak-up channels, and misconduct investigations on the other. Firms that treat fitness checks as "optional now" instead of "more targeted now" will get blindsided when an investigation goes sideways.
What Good Fitness and Propriety Looks Like in Practice
When firms over-rely on annual tick-box exercises, they often miss real red flags. A manager can click "approved" on an annual form without ever checking whether a senior trader or advisor is under quiet strain, bypassing controls, or creating a toxic desk.
Real oversight works differently. In my experience, strong firms separate routine administration from meaningful judgment:
- They document why someone is fit and proper at hiring, promotion, or role change, rather than recycling last year's copy-paste note.
- They keep clear records when allegations, complaints, or disciplinary matters arise—even inconclusive ones where context still matters for regulatory references.
- They make sure Senior Managers know their exact boundaries and have real visibility into risks inside their patch, not just a binder on a shelf.
There's also a real debate here about growth versus guardrails. Supporters argue Britain was losing talent and speed because hiring a senior specialist took months of regulatory waiting. Critics argue that relaxing checks on the back of a growth push risks repeating the hubris that preceded 2008. Both concerns are credible, which is why the consultation period—running into January 2027—matters so much.
Practical Steps for Firms and Professionals Right Now
Because Phase 2 is out for consultation rather than final law, firms shouldn't rip up their current compliance playbooks overnight. A smart move right now is to prepare cleanly without creating double work:
- Keep current SM&CR and certification processes running until final rules and legislative changes take effect.
- Audit your non-financial misconduct and investigation workflows against the September 2026 COCON and FIT expectations. Make sure escalation paths and investigation notes are consistent and fair.
- Map affected Senior Manager Functions and certified populations now so you know which roles could shift from pre-approval to notification or drop out of mandatory annual certification.
- Tighten internal hiring and reference checks. Less external pre-approval means greater internal responsibility to prove you vetted people properly.
- Review consultation details from the Bank of England and PRA and the Financial Conduct Authority before the consultation closes on 22 January 2027, and submit feedback if specific thresholds or role changes affect your business.